16 replies to this topic

[fuzz94]

Votes need logical reasoning behind them unless the number falls into the same area as other votes.
Vote for both routes if it applies to the unit.
Please make your vote out of 10, 100, etc. so it's easy to calculate the averages.
Please ignore the Tower of Valni for this. Any unit can become great using it. That said, if you want to rank based on how they perform in more casual play, go for it.
You can add or subtract at most 1 (and I must emphasize 1) point for a bias on character or appearance.
If I feel you vote does not meet these requirements, I will ask you to revise your review/score. I will not just throw your vote out without informing you, but I will throw out votes if you don't change your rating when I ask you.
If you are adding a bias include it total, not score plus biad and leave me to figure out if your score includes it or not
If you are going to take the liberty of starting a topic when I can't, please follow Ephraim's route and not throw random people in/confuse it with Eirika's Route.

Gilliam: 1.625
Knoll: 2.43
Eph. Marisa: 3.136
Neimi: 3.49
Eir. Marisa: 3.59
Ewan: 3.84
Amelia: 3.89
Orson: 4.0
Rennac: 4.0833
L'Arachel: 4.333
Lute: 4.875
Tethys: 5.0
Eph. Innes: 5.281
Ross: 5.33
Garcia: 5.43
Natasha: 5.625
Eir. Duessel: 5.86
Eir. Innes: 6.91
Eirika: 6.2
Moulder: 6.4
Eir. Ephraim: 6.5
Eph. Saleh: 6.94
Dozla: 6.987
Forde: 7.167
Colm: 7.25
Artur: 7.33
Kyle: 7.375
Vanessa: 7.5
Eir. Saleh: 7.86
Joshua: 8.0
Eph. Duessel: 8.07
Franz: 8.12
Eph. Gerik: 8.45
Tana: 8.58
Eir. Cormag: 8.58
Eir. Gerik: 8.8
Eph. Ephraim: 8.92
Eph. Cormag: 9.42
Seth: 9.75

BOOM 10/10
Why? Because at base nothing can kill her, and easily gains levels and just gets better. Only issue is join time but she would be 20/20 and have the dragonstone broken by the endgame if she came earlier

[Ristau]

9/10 because she has a limited weapon. Too bad that she comes late enough that it doesn't matter, so she can not waste it too bad. She also has killer growths, and sick weapon bonuses.
+1 for being a "cute little girl"

10/10

[fuzz94]

QUOTE (Ryokutheman @ Jul 5 2012, 12:47 AM)

9/10 because she has a limited weapon. Too bad that she comes late enough that it doesn't matter, so she can not waste it too bad. She also has killer growths, and sick weapon bonuses. +1 for being a "MOTHER ****IN' DRAGON" 10/10

I think that's what you meant.

[Rujio]

She can't be 20/20, fuzz

When you're playing for turns, Myrrh doesn't really have much to offer. By the time she joins, people like Franz, Ephraim, Kyle, and Cormag are all going around with more MOV than her and, thanks to her poor SPD, better combat. She can't get to the enemies to get the EXP she needs to put those insane growths to use, and if she can't even get there for EXP, she certainly can't get places to help you.

2/10

[Ristau]

QUOTE (fuzz94 @ Jul 4 2012, 10:44 PM)

Please make your vote out of 10, 100, etc. so it's easy to calculate the averages.

QUOTE (Rujio @ Jul 4 2012, 11:57 PM)

She can't be 20/20, fuzz

I think it falls under the category XD
hmm... I still think she's better than that piece of shit Franz that you claim is so good

[Lancer]

10 + 1 = 11/10

Dragon Loli who kicks lots of ass. Does lots of damage, gains lots of EXP, has lots of defense and resistance, possesses God-like growths, and doesn't afraid of anything.

[Ristau]

Is she afraid of Azaka?

[Lancer]

Okay, I take that back. Is only afraid of other dragon lolis :3

[Oblivion Knight]

Myrrh shows up late and is limited by her 50 use Dragon Stone, in other words you only get 50 attacks with her. She's amazing for Darkling Woods on account of her stone being effective against monsters, although she has a weakness to arrows which leaves her slightly in danger. Other than that she's pretty solid for the monster chapter filled chapters and the final chapter. Even though she's good for all of this, she still shows up playable too late into the game and limited attacking basically equals useless if you spam her so much her stone breaks. ._.

4/10

[Falaflame]

5+1/10 --> 6/10

She gets the dead-average vote because she's usable, but comes way too late and other units are already pulling their own weight well. But she get's the bias point because she's so adorable. ^//^;;

[SmashedFish]

4/10 +1 = 5/10

She's effective, sure, but you only need to use her to take the easy way out of a terrible team setup. If you don't, odds are your team would be better off without her. Her supports are heartwarming (Eph) and hilarious (Dozla), though, so she gets my bias.

[fuzz94]

@ry he means level 20/20 meaning she doesn't promote. My bad. I meant just level 20

[Rujio]

QUOTE (Ryokutheman @ Jul 4 2012, 11:20 PM)

QUOTE (fuzz94 @ Jul 4 2012, 10:44 PM) Please make your vote out of 10, 100, etc. so it's easy to calculate the averages. QUOTE (Rujio @ Jul 4 2012, 11:57 PM) She can't be 20/20, fuzz I think it falls under the category XD hmm... I still think she's better than that piece of shit Franz that you claim is so good

I meant her level :{ I give up on Franz, but I'll just say one thing: Say I'm playing FE6 and Niime gets a perfect level up on every level up and Karel gets +2 to HP and + 1 to everything else. Does this mean that, besides HP, Niime's growths are as good as Karel's? It's the same thing with Franz and, say, Amelia. You can have an amazing Amelia and a crappy Franz, but that doesn't mean that overall Franz is worse than Amelia. Actually, I would still be inclined to argue that Franz is better than Amelia there...

[fuzz94]

QUOTE (Rujio @ Jul 5 2012, 11:06 AM)

I meant her level :{ I give up on Franz, but I'll just say one thing: Say I'm playing FE6 and Niime gets a perfect level up on every level up and Karel gets +2 to HP and + 1 to everything else. Does this mean that, besides HP, Niime's growths are as good as Karel's? It's the same thing with Franz and, say, Amelia. You can have an amazing Amelia and a crappy Franz, but that doesn't mean that overall Franz is worse than Amelia. Actually, I would still be inclined to argue that Franz is better than Amelia there...

FE6 is broken. Like entirely, the growths are all screwed to hell, so comparing anything to FE6 is not something you should do.

[Bobryk]

Hmm...Myrrh...tough one.

She doesn't need to be abused but she does need a little bit of babying. She can probably hit lvl 20 in the first chapter you face monsters on, though (after she becomes playable of course).

(If I use Myrrh I have her solo a skirmish and she's lvl 20 in less than 5 minutes, but we're discounting skirmishes here.)

But if she's not fighting monsters she's pointless to use.

Her joining chapter, IIRC, is the one where you take back Renais, so she's useless there. Then it's the river? Useless there too. Then it's...gorgons? She can do something there, be it eggs or regular gorgons. (Though anyone can kill eggs so she's not exactly helping, she's just being trained.)

I'd say her only feasible level to gain experience is darkling woods, but she'll max out very quickly there. And of course her stats are quite amazing.

So, uh, TL;DR Useless in non-monster chapters, 50 attacks and she's unusable, terrible join time, when maxed is best unit you have against most monsters (imo) to equal:

3.5/10

[bblues]

Pretty late join time, stone is kinda cool, but only 50 uses. Kicks monsters, but so do most people by that point in the game. I guess she has a use in, what, the last two chapters? That's about it really.

Eh...4/10 for me. Low usage weapon, late join, low use for chapters. However, can be useful, especially if you somehow get major RNG screwage on your units.

[SilentSentinel]

3/10

Low move, late join time, limited use weapon.